“August: Osage County”
Starring: Meryl Streep, Julia Roberts, Chris Cooper, Ewan McGregor, Margo Martindale, Sam Shepard, Dermot Mulroney, Julianne Nicholson, Juliette Lewis, Abigail Breslin, Benedict Cumberbatch, Misty Upham
Rating: R, for frequent profanity and earthy dialogue, and brief drug content
Strong cast has a field day with dysfunction family dynamics
By Derrick Bang
Enterprise film critic
Some children dream, worshipfully, of growing up to become just like their parents.
Other children have nightmares about that same possibility.
“August: Osage County,” adapted by Tracy Letts from his Pulitzer Prize-winning play, charts the highs (very few) and lows (too many to tabulate) of the extended Weston family, brought by unexpected tragedy to the Northern Oklahoma town that several of them fled, years ago, in self-defense.
Although Oklahoma isn’t technically a southern state, the tone here is very much in the dysfunctional Southern gothic tradition of Tennessee Williams, Beth Henley and numerous other playwrights who regard this classic American setting as less a geographical place, and more a regional attitude.
Be advised: Despite its mesmerizing script and bravura performances, “August: Osage County” is an endurance test in the manner of “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf.” It’s not easy to watch people eviscerate each other for two hours, no matter how crisp the dialogue, or how striking the acting.
Most of the slicing and dicing emanates from family matriarch Violet Weston (Meryl Streep), an embittered, waspish harridan embracing old age with no grace whatsoever. Demonstrating that God does indeed possess a mordant sense of humor, Violet has just been diagnosed with mouth cancer, which has exacerbated her tendency to be a prescription junkie.
But the cancer diagnosis isn’t the catalyst for the impromptu reunion, at least not directly. Violet’s husband Beverly (Sam Shepard), once a respected poet and author now content to slide into comfortable alcoholism, has gone on another of his infrequent “sojourns,” no doubt to escape his wife’s nasty tongue. But the circumstances are a bit different this time, because before departing he hired a young woman, Johnna (Misty Upham), to cook and clean. And that isn’t like him.
Violet’s sister Mattie Fae (Margo Martindale) hits the panic button, which assembles the troops. Violet’s eldest daughter Barbara (Julia Roberts), expecting only that her mother will need another stint in rehab, arrives with 14-year-old daughter Jean (Abigail Breslin) and estranged husband Bill (Ewan McGregor) in tow. Barbara and Bill, not having disclosed their marital discord, have agreed to play nice for the sake of family harmony.
We can imagine, given Violet’s watchful eye and sharp instincts, how long that secret will last.
Youngest Weston daughter Karen (Juliette Lewis) arrives next, with flashy new fiancé Steve (Dermot Mulroney) at the wheel of his red sports car. One glimpse of Steve, and we know he’s Bad News; we also deduce that Karen has made a career of wretched relationship choices, a failing that she defends during a stream-of-consciousness whine with Barbara.
We’ve already met middle daughter Ivy (Julianne Nicholson), because she’s the one who stayed behind, to watch over her parents … and mostly to function as a meek whipping post for her mother’s relentless lashings.
The clan is completed by Mattie Fae’s husband Charlie (Chris Cooper) and their son, Little Charles (Benedict Cumberbatch). Charlie is a kind-hearted pillar of integrity who does his best to maintain order and/or keep the peace under increasingly combustible circumstances; Little Charles, suffering from galloping insecurity, barely seems able to function in the big, wide world.
Although Letts’ script finds ample reasons for smaller subsets of these characters to mingle and chew at each other, during the several days that this narrative occupies, the film’s galvanic scene comes the one time everybody assembles around the massive dinner table. This soon-to-be-tempestuous meal also begins with the film’s funniest moment, as poor Charlie struggles with the demand that he lead a prayer. Never has anybody been less equipped for such an assignment, and Cooper flounders for what seems like days, while Streep’s eyes narrow in ever-greater exasperation, and we wait for the inevitable outburst.
It’s difficult to know where to start, with a cast this strong. Certainly Streep and Roberts deserve their Oscar nominations — actress and supporting actress, respectively — but director John Wells gets everybody to bring their A-game. Even Upham, in the quietest role — Johnna being a mostly passive observer — gets her moment to shine, in an unexpected manner.
Cinema has no shortage of actresses who’ve memorably tackled the “mother from hell” role, but Streep, as she so often does, re-defines the template; her Violet is the stuff of nightmares, from the moment she first stumbles down the stairs, drug-intoxicated and hurling spiteful profanity like a dock worker.
As the film progresses, though, our sense of Violet shifts. To be sure, she’s a miserably cruel human being, but we can’t help admiring her survival instincts. More to the point, despite her many and varied flaws, Violet emerges as a figure of pity: somebody we know will, one day, wind up dying alone. That Streep draws such complex feelings from us, is nothing short of amazing. But it’s not merely her performance: Excellent as it is, she gets considerable ammunition from Letts’ perceptive and provocative dialogue.
Our impression, going in, is that Violet will be the focus of her own story. That’s not entirely true, because Violet is incapable of change. We gradually realize that Barbara is the key player here, because, despite every effort to do otherwise, she has become that which she most despises. She’s a terrible mother herself, wholly unable to cope with Jean’s premature (and quite clumsy) march into adulthood.
The question, then, is whether Barbara can surmount her own upbringing, and Roberts’ brutal, tight-lipped performance evokes the tragedy of a woman who can’t claw her way out of the purgatory she built for herself.
Lewis, with a string of flakes in her performance past, is right at home with Karen’s chronic anxiety. She feigns carefree insouciance, but it’s a pose. Watch her, during the aforementioned dinner scene; Lewis sits, stricken and silent, her face a portrait of terror, waiting for the verbal strike that would shatter her like glass.
Nicholson’s Ivy, though, is the heartbreaker. Her face isn’t quite a perfect mask, although Ivy clearly tries to withhold true feelings, the better to minimize any vulnerabilities that Violet might exploit. Nicholson’s gentle, wary performance evokes memories of Laura Winfield, from “The Glass Menagerie”: the same fragility and, we deduce, isolation from a world — a life — that has passed her by.
I’m always fascinated by the ease with which British actors slip into Deep South Americana characters; both McGregor and Cumberbatch do so effortlessly here. We don’t get a strong sense of McGregor’s Bill, although it’s not hard to imagine that his marital transgressions likely were self-defense as, over time, Barbara became more and more like her mother.
Cumberbatch, though, is a revelation: his Little Charles the frightened-bird antithesis of the Sherlock Holmes who strides so confidently across our TV screens these days. Between this film and “12 Years a Slave,” Cumberbatch demonstrates an impressive range, and an uncanny ability to inhabit such decisively American roles.
Shepard opens the film, both on camera and with an off-camera narrative voice — poetic and laden with weary regret — that perfectly sets the stage for what is to follow.
Considering this material’s origins, Wells and Letts “open it up” quite well; we never get the sense of claustrophobia that sometimes afflicts stage-to-film adaptations. Credit cinematographer Adriano Goldman, as well, for so deftly conveying the oppressive heat; his images almost shimmer with soul-draining fever.
Watching such a roster of scene-stealing actors work their way through such material is never less than exciting, even as the unfolding drama becomes increasingly difficult to endure. To reference the old cliché, it’s like watching a slow-motion train wreck; we want to look away, but can’t.
And, similarly, you won’t soon forget many of this film’s blisteringly vivid confrontations.
— Read more of Derrick Bang’s film criticism at http://derrickbang.blogspot.com. Comment on this review at www.davisenterprise.com. Be sure to join Derrick during the first three Sunday evenings in February, when he hosts the Classic Film Festival at the Davis Odd Fellows Hall.