Sunday, April 20, 2014

More crude-by-rail trains put Davis at risk


Oil cars are 60 feet long, and most oil trains contain 50 to 100 cars. Some oil trains already come through Davis, and if Benicia's Planning Commission approves Valero's proposal to build a rail terminal, a 100-car-long oil train will pass through Davis every day. Richard McAdam/Courtesy photo

By Lynne Nittler, Milton Kalish and Matt Biers-Ariel

North Dakota Bakken crude oil production is booming, and oil companies are desperate for a fast, convenient way to transport their crude oil to refineries across the United States. A vast network of railroads crisscross the nation, making “unit trains,” pulling 100 oil tank cars or more, an efficient and flexible method of transportation.

In the past few years, crude-by-rail shipments have increased tenfold. In 2013, railroads hauled more than 2 million barrels in California, and in 2014 that number may skyrocket to 50 million barrels or more, according to California Energy Commission data.

We don’t know just how many oil trains came through Davis in 2013, but if Bay Area refineries such as Valero in Benicia have their way, crude oil trains will soon be coming through Davis every day this year.

Never mind the added carbon dioxide entering the atmosphere by burning Bakken Shale oil; California and the United States should not be expanding or even facilitating fossil fuel infrastructure at a time when we should leave fossil fuel in the ground and pursue renewables instead.

But the long trains of tank cars with their volatile cargo pose an immediate health and safety risk. Last July, 47 people perished in a massive fireball when a train containing Bakken crude derailed and exploded in the Canadian town of Lac-Megantic, Quebec. Four more oil trains have derailed in Canada since then.

In November, a train carrying the same Bakken crude derailed in Alabama. Twelve of the cars exploded, fortunately, not in a populated area. In the last week of December, another 18 tank cars carrying Bakken crude derailed and exploded two miles outside Casselton, N.D. The town was urged to evacuate to avoid the plumes of toxic smoke from the ensuing fires that burned for more than a day.

And again last week, another oil train derailed and exploded in Canada.

Sometimes, trains carrying the same highly flammable material in the same outdated DOT-111 tank cars pass through the center of our hometown. The propensity for these tanker cars to rupture and explode on impact make them the Ford Pinto of the rails. Furthermore, it’s becoming clear that the chemical composition of Bakken Shale oil itself is highly explosive.

The tank cars mostly transport the flammable Bakken crude from North Dakota, but some Alberta Tar Sands bitumen also passes through Davis. On the way to the five Bay Area refineries, the tank cars pass through Roseville, Sacramento, West Sacramento, Davis, Dixon and Suisun, crossing sensitive natural areas including the American and Sacramento rivers, the Yolo Bypass, then cutting through the protected Suisun Marshes to travel alongside Interstate 680 to Benicia.

Train companies extol the safety of oil trains, but recent accidents clearly show that the health and safety of our families and community are put at risk with each train. The risk is increasing as each of the five Bay Area refineries plans to process more Bakken and tar sands crude, from both increased crude-by-rail and boat shipments. Valero Benicia is only one of several proposed Bay Area projects that impact Davis.

Last summer, Valero petitioned Benicia to allow the oil refinery to enlarge its train terminal in order to increase its production by 70,000 barrels of crude every day. That’s enough to fill 100 60-foot-long tank cars with highly flammable crude oil. The Benicia Planning Commission has the power to approve the new rail terminal, or turn it down. Responding to pressure from citizens and a study prepared by the National Resources Defense Council, Benicia is preparing a draft environmental impact report for the project that should be available for written public comments by the end of January.

So what can Davis residents do? Though the city of Davis cannot regulate trains that pass through it, we are far from helpless. Since significantly increasing the number of trains to Benicia affects us in Davis, concerned citizens and our elected representatives can take advantage of the 45-day written comment period on the draft EIR. Davisites can work with our City Council and Yolo County Board of Supervisors to submit comments with supporting evidence that address at least the following concerns:

* The old DOT-111 tank cars need to be upgraded or replaced by safer tank cars with thicker shells and puncture- and rupture-resistant shields, stronger valve fittings to prevent spills and fires if the cars should derail, and tanks that can withstand corrosive sulfur.

The recent oil company order for 60,000 new DOT-111 tank cars should be canceled unless they are upgraded models. This will be very costly for the industry, but protecting the public is critical.

* The Bakken crude has proved to be more corrosive, sulfurous or loaded with explosive gas than previously thought, and large amounts of vapor pressure can build up to dangerous levels. Already, the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration has issued a safety alert to notify the general public, first responders and shippers and carriers that recent derailments and resulting fires indicate that the type of oil being transported from the Bakken region may be more flammable than traditional heavy crude oil.

The safety administration is reinforcing the requirement to properly test, characterize, classify and where appropriate sufficiently degasify hazardous material (known as flaring) prior to and during transportation.

Trains of Bakken crude should be placed in a higher-risk hazardous materials category. Accurate labeling will in turn determine how the Bakken crude can be transported. The proper management and transport of the Bakken crude also may be costly, but safety demands it as trains run through city centers across the country.

* Safety regulations for rail transport, including regular inspections ,must be thoroughly reviewed and then strictly enforced by the federal government. There is evidence that enforcement has been lax.

* Problems caused by under-crewed trains, track failures, speeding downhill, obstacles on tracks and other problems that have caused derailments in recent months need to be specifically addressed by the federal government.

* Remove the exemption for rail shipments of hazardous materials for the Emergency Planning and Right-to-Know law, so communities at risk can be informed of risks they are subject to if they are living or working near rail lines. This includes the nature, volume and frequency of hazardous materials shipments and what to do to be prepared in case of an accident.

Emergency responders need to be aware of any hazards posed by the materials being transported through their communities, and plans for a coordinated response need to be developed.

* The health, safety and environmental concerns of all up-rail communities need to be taken into consideration and fully mitigated, according to the outcome of the ongoing investigations of recent derailments and explosions and the degree of exposure to risks.

It is critical that Davis and all up-rail cities get involved at this point. It would be wise for the up-rail communities to make comments in concert to amplify their effectiveness. Davis has an opportunity to reach out to its neighbors in Roseville, Sacramento, West Sacramento, Woodland, Dixon, Vacaville, Fairfield and Suisun who will share the same risks to their health and well-being as crude-by-rail transportation increases.

The Yolo County Board of Supervisors also should be invited to join in a united response, along with environmental groups such as the Natural Resources Defense Council, Sierra Club Yolano Group, Sierra Club Mother Lode chapter, Yolano Climate Action (a Cool Davis working group including 350 Davis and, and other interested groups.

Building a strong coalition now will help as Tesoro Martinez and Wes-Pac Pittsburg Energy have proposals for more crude-by-rail that also may come through Davis. Ultimately, a strong voice will give additional leverage to demanding intervention at the federal level.

The city of Davis Natural Resources Commission has added crude-by-rail transport and comments for the Benicia Valero EIR to its Jan. 27 meeting agenda. The commission will meet at 6:30 p.m. that day in the Community Chambers at City Hall, 23 Russell Blvd. The public is welcome.

An annotated list of reference information with links to articles and Natural Resources Defense Council reports is available in the handout materials provided to the NRC members. Digital copies are available for download at

— The authors are all Davis residents.

Special to The Enterprise


Discussion | 10 comments

The Davis Enterprise does not necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Read our full policy

  • January 12, 2014 - 5:32 am

    So I take it all the authors of this piece don't drive cars, take trains, ride buses or fly in airplanes?

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Noreen MazelisJanuary 12, 2014 - 12:38 pm

    Nope; they all use horse-driven buggies, the better to fertilize Davis -- and the rest of Yolo County.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Damien LuzzoJanuary 23, 2014 - 10:23 am

    Cars, trains, buses, planes... assuming this comment was aimed at making a point about fossil fuels, here's a fun fact: Before the industrial revolution, these never existed. And in places like Germany, all of these things are electric. And you don't need planes... you can do rail, car, and bus via electricity. And besides horses and bikes, you do have two feet for a reason.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Rich RifkinJanuary 12, 2014 - 1:29 pm

    If the authors want to reduce the danger to the people of Davis from trains passing through with crude oil, they should be loudly calling for new pipelines which can safely and more cheaply transport crude. Pipelines can be routed far from cities like Davis and take the petroleum directly to refineries. Unfortunately, the same activists who are demonstrating against trains transporting crude have opposed the creation of new crude pipelines. It's almost as if these folks are really not very smart.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Alan MillerJanuary 12, 2014 - 2:24 pm

    And yes, RR, though I agree with much of what the authors suggest in my comments below, the reason I initially distanced myself is the same people calling for this are based on anti-oil politics which I support in my dream world of how the world should be, but it isn't going to happen by blocking pipelines which only push the oil to market by rail. This is were I will not see eye-to-eye with the authors. Pipelines are the mid-term solution to the rail-transport hazards. In the short term, we must address the very real hazardous to populations in this coming boom (pun intended) of oil-by-rail transport.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Damien LuzzoJanuary 23, 2014 - 10:37 am

    Rich, pipelines are indeed cheaper. But the authors aren't trying to reduce "crude-by-rail danger", they are trying to reduce the danger of "crude transportation".... If this was a pipeline project, they would be against the pipeline project for very similar reasons. The problem isn't the train, the problem is the danger that the train presents the city of Davis due to the unconventional sources of crude that they are transporting. This has everything to do with the fact that this transported Oil is Bakken Shale Bitumen and Tar Sands Crude. In Alberta Canada, for example, there has been an oil spill every other day, on average, for the last 37 years. Pipelines and crude-by-rail... regardless of the poison you choose, so long as they are trying to transport these heavier or more volatile crude oils, both methods of transportation are dangerous, extremely hazardous and an accident waiting to happen. I think these folks are plenty smart. Maybe you should google pipeline safety before you comment.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Alan MillerJanuary 12, 2014 - 2:18 pm

    Anonymous commenter and NM, your sarcastic attitude towards environmentalists is misplaced and misguided in this case. I am not an anti-oil activist and I support transport by rail of hazardous materials. I changed my stance on the transport of Bakken oil since the previous article after extensively looking into the recent wrecks. The threat to the populations along the line are real, and a very real weakness in Union Pacific's track structure in Davis puts the center of Davis especially at risk; I am documenting this and will present. The authors of the article miss a few key techical points about transport, however the gist of this article is spot on. I tire of much far-left environmentalist rhetoric as it borders on the impossible-to-implement. This one is real. The recommendations they give are real, and I will add one more specific soon that will make the transport of oil through Davis that much safer.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • January 12, 2014 - 3:02 pm

    If anyone cares to research how much money, tax breaks, subsidies, etc. in the form of our tax dollars, have been given to fossil fuel industries, and imagine those dollars going into renewables, one can see the solution would be shortly forth-coming. And BTW, NM, I've never seen a horse driven buggy explode.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Greg JohnsonJanuary 13, 2014 - 1:07 pm

    Green energy, if feasible, is something everybody should support. However, the idea that the money from these "tax breaks", etc. would make green energy a viable alternative is groundless. If there is money to be made, the private sector will me there to make it. With green energy, it could be an energy of activation situation where there is up front initial investment after which it will be economically sound. Or, it could be that it is just more expensive, but maybe that additional expense will be required for environmental reasons.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Alan MillerJanuary 14, 2014 - 1:30 pm

    Agreed, just check out what has happened to the ethanol "boom".

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Recent Posts

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this newspaper and receive notifications of new articles by email.

  • .


    A springtime ritual

    By Wayne Tilcock | From Page: A1 | Gallery

    Tom Adams seeks Davis school board seat

    By Jeff Hudson | From Page: A1

    Hub of activity: DHS newspaper keeps evolving

    By Zoe Juanitas | From Page: A1 | Gallery

    Holy fire ceremony draws thousands in Jerusalem

    By The Associated Press | From Page: A2 | Gallery

    Tour renovated YCCC facility Thursday

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A3

    Tour Davis Waldorf School on Wednesday

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A3

    The fifth annual Tour de Cluck is soon to be hatched

    By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: A3 | Gallery

    Ortiz lawn signs available

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A3

    Sign up soon for spring cooking classes

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A3

    Robb Davis team to rally on Saturday

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A3

    Steadfast in their support

    By Lauren Keene | From Page: A4, 7 Comments | Gallery

    Yolo Hospice offers free grief workshops

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A4

    Sign up for Camp Kesem caterpillar crawl

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A4

    Quilters gear up for annual show

    By Sebastian Onate | From Page: A4

    KDVS launches fund drive on Monday

    By Jeff Hudson | From Page: A5

    Calling all Scrabble fans

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5, 1 Comment | Gallery

    League hosts a series of candidate forums

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5

    Hub webpage is seeing traffic increasing

    By Zoe Juanitas | From Page: A8

    Preschool open house set at Davis Waldorf

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A16

    Birch Lane celebrates its 50th anniversary

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A16

    Hotel/conference center info meeting set

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A16

    Lescroart welcomes all to book-launch party

    By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: A16 | Gallery

    DEVO set to serve up 14th annual Winkler Dinner

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A16 | Gallery

    Learn Chinese crafts at I-House

    By Sebastian Onate | From Page: A16



    Take ownership of your health

    By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: B5

    Not thrilled with lack of symmetry

    By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: A7

    Reliving the agony and ecstasy of spring

    By Marion Franck | From Page: A7

    Keep your baby safe

    By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: A7

    Core values on campus

    By Our View | From Page: A12, 1 Comment

    Road diet? No, city diet!

    By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A12, 5 Comments

    We’re reveling in our equality

    By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A12, 1 Comment

    Vote no; it’s fiscally responsible

    By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A12, 2 Comments

    Rick McKee cartoon

    By Debbie Davis | From Page: A12

    Bill is an affront to UC Davis ag biotech and local farmers

    By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: A13, 1 Comment

    Don’t want to sit in Fix 50 traffic? Consider alternatives

    By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: A13, 1 Comment



    Devils burn up the track

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: B1

    UCD softball shut out by Santa Barbara

    By Thomas Oide | From Page: B1 | Gallery

    Aggie men shoot 9-under, lead own tourney

    By Bruce Gallaudet | From Page: B1 | Gallery

    Stars shine in Woody Wilson Classic

    By Evan Ream | From Page: B1, 1 Comment | Gallery

    UCD roundup: Aggie baseball swept away by Highlanders

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: B2

    A’s score 3 in ninth, rally past Astros 4-3

    By The Associated Press | From Page: B6







    Yolo Federal Credit Union gets WISH funds

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A9

    PG&E pays taxes, fees to county, cities

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A9, 1 Comment

    Will Davis get an Old Soul?

    By Wendy Weitzel | From Page: A9

    Pediatricians, nurse practitioner hired at Woodland Healthcare

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A9 | Gallery

    Asian stocks mostly higher after mixed U.S. earnings

    By The Associated Press | From Page: A9

    Davis Roots will showcase its graduating startups

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A14

    University Honda wins another President’s Award

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A14 | Gallery

    Dutch Bros. raises $19,000 for girl with leukemia

    By Enterprise staff | From Page: A14 | Gallery





    Comics: Sunday, April 20, 2014

    By Creator | From Page: B8