Thursday, April 24, 2014

Per Capita Davis: Is nuclear power worth the dangers?


From page A3 | February 16, 2012 | Leave Comment

Well, I can’t put it off any longer. A small newspaper article buried deep in the interior pages on Sunday announced that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has granted a license for two new nuclear reactors to be built in the state of Georgia. The plant will take a while to build — estimates are it could begin producing power in 2016 — and there certainly could be delays between now and then.

But still, the tiny announcement raises a huge question that I don’t have an answer to: What do I think about nuclear energy?

It used to be simpler. Whether for real or imagined reasons, there has not been a new license issued in the United States since 1978, when Jimmy Carter was president, a gallon of gas cost 79 cents, and the first cell phone was introduced.

The Three Mile Island nuclear near-meltdown was in 1979 and since that event, nuclear power has been, at least in this country, judged to be too risky.

Certainly, the nuclear industry continued to advocate for this source of power, but public opinion held it to be too dangerous, for several reasons: Nuclear power plants can blow up or leak radiation, there’s no safe place to store the waste and for all practical purposes it lasts forever, and even if there were a place to dispose of the waste no one wants it transported from the plant through their city or town to the waste dump.

Not insignificantly, some nuclear waste could be used to build atomic bombs, something the planet does not need more of. And besides, until recently, electrical energy was cheap and the threat of climate change was not yet in the public mind.

Back when I was in college and sitting around very late at night with other undergraduate English majors discussing with deep seriousness what we took to be the greater philosophical issues of the human condition, one of the participants asked a question that sparked general hilarity: “If you’re standing up to your neck in a vat of rhinoceros poop (not an exact quote) and someone throws a bucket of elephant vomit at you, would you duck?”

This is where I am with the question of the role of nuclear power in our energy future. On the one hand, it’s carbon-free and to the extent that it replaces either new or existing coal plants it would be a positive in terms of climate change. But it comes with very serious risks, as we have seen at Chernobyl (1986), and most recently with Fukushima (2011).

Nuclear proponents argue that the fears that derailed the nuclear industry are no longer as relevant as they once were. Risk cannot be eliminated, but nuclear power is said to be safer with significantly lower incidence of accidents (unless, perhaps, you build one in the path of a tsunami).

Proponents also argue that new technology substantially reduces the risk of proliferation of nuclear weapons and point out that 30 countries operate nuclear power plants, with France leading the way with nearly 80 percent of its electricity coming from this source.

Others point out that we have new worries: Nuclear power plants could be targets for terrorism, for example, and nuclear plants sited near population centers (17 million people live within a 50-mile radius of Indian Point in New York) are prime targets.

And it’s not like it never happens: Since 1980, there have been nearly a dozen attacks against nuclear power plants in Iran, Iraq, Syria and Israel.

So, when I’m confused, I turn to the experts. There are two I look to most for their opinions on matters related to climate change. One is Bill McKibben, who has been a powerful voice on the subject of global warming and is spearheading the campaign to bring atmospheric concentrations of CO2 to safer levels.

The other is James Hansen, who was one of the first and over time the most consistent ringer of the warning bell about the adverse consequences of climate change. The trouble is, they’re on opposite sides of the issue.

McKibben says no to nuclear power, pointing out the dangers. Hansen says the technology has improved, the risks have been reduced substantially, and more than anything else the problem of global warming is so serious (think rhinoceros poop) that we have to include nuclear energy in our response. No help here, other than to reinforce my confusion.

Another hero, Amory Lovins, is coming to Davis later this month to make his case for why he thinks we don’t need nuclear to get out of the way of the global warming train wreck; he says we can do it all with solar and other renewables. His is not a universally shared opinion.

I hope I’m not boring you with all this back-and-forth. It seems to me that many of the people I have brought this up with have a similar confusion or ambivalence, with smart, thoughtful people on both sides.

This is going to take more than one column. In the meantime, I’d appreciate any thoughts anyone might have on this topic.

— John Mott-Smith is a somewhat confused resident of Davis. This column is published on the first and third Thursdays of each month. Send comments to

John Mott-Smith


Discussion | No comments

The Davis Enterprise does not necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Read our full policy



Will city move forward on public power review?

By Dave Ryan | From Page: A1

4-H members get ready for Spring Show

By Anne Ternus-Bellamy | From Page: A1 | Gallery

Obama to Russia: More sanctions are ‘teed up’

By The Associated Press | From Page: A2, 3 Comments

2 pursuits, 2 arrests keep Woodland officers busy

By Lauren Keene | From Page: A2

Conference puts focus on Arab studies

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A4

Youth sports in focus on radio program

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A4

Rummage sale will benefit preschool

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A4

Concert benefits South Korea exchange

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A4

Davis honors ‘green’ citizens

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5

Water rate assistance bill advances

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5

Program explores STEM careers for girls

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5, 4 Comments

Embroiderers plan a hands-on project

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5

Central Park Gardens to host Volunteer Orientation Day

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5 | Gallery

Volkssporting Club plans North Davis walks

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5

Hotel/conference center info meeting set

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A5

MOMS Club plans open house

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A7

Cycle de Mayo benefits Center for Families

By Anne Ternus-Bellamy | From Page: A8

Author to read ‘The Cat Who Chose to Dream’

By Anne Ternus-Bellamy | From Page: A12



Things are turning sour

By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: B5

Tom Meyer cartoon

By Debbie Davis | From Page: A6

The high cost of employment

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A6, 1 Comment

High-five to Union Bank

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A6

Broken sprinklers waste water

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A6

Three more administrators?

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A6

Neustadt has experience for the job

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A6

Here’s a plan to save big on employee costs

By Special to The Enterprise | From Page: A6, 4 Comments

Davis is fair, thoughtful

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A6

Ortiz is the right choice for Yolo

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A6



DHS tracksters sweep another DVC meet

By Enterprise staff | From Page: B1 | Gallery

Another DVC blowout for DHS girls soccer

By Evan Ream | From Page: B1, 2 Comments | Gallery

Young reinvents his game to help Aggies improve on the diamond

By Bruce Gallaudet | From Page: B1 | Gallery

DHS boys shuffle the deck to beat Cards

By Thomas Oide | From Page: B1 | Gallery

DHS/Franklin II is a close loss for Devil softballers

By Enterprise staff | From Page: B1

Baseball roundup: Giants slam Rockies in the 11th

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2

UCD roundup: Aggies lose a softball game at Pacific

By Enterprise staff | From Page: B3

Jahn jumps to Sacramento Republic FC

By Evan Ream | From Page: B8





Bach Soloists wrap up season on April 28

By Jeff Hudson | From Page: A11

Congressional art competition open to high school students

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A11

Emerson, Da Vinci to present ‘Once Upon a Mattress’

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A11

Winters Plein Air Festival begins Friday

By Enterprise staff | From Page: A11







Comics: Thursday, April 24, 2014

By Creator | From Page: B6